Two Loan Offers Calculator

See which loan offer costs less over its full term.

How it is calculated

The same loan amount is run through each offer's rate and term with the level-payment formula.

i = rate ÷ 100 ÷ 12, n = years × 12
payment = P × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)−n)
total cost = payment × n
difference = total cost A − total cost B

P is the loan amount in dollars. A positive difference means offer A costs more over its full term; a negative one, shown with the sign before the dollar sign (-$50,341.14), means offer B does. At a 0% rate the payment is simply P ÷ n. The results list both monthly payments and the total cost of offer B, so offer A's total is the B total plus the difference. Each term must come to a whole number of months (4.25 years is fine, 4.1 is not) and be at most 100 years; the amount must be above zero and rates cannot be negative, or there is no result. Total cost means principal plus interest only: origination fees, insurance and points are not included, and APR is not calculated.

Worked example

You need $20,000 and have two quotes: offer A at 6.9% over 5 years and offer B at 7.5% over 4 years. A: monthly rate 0.575%, 60 payments, payment $395.08, total about $23,704.86. B: monthly rate 0.625%, 48 payments, payment $483.58, total $23,211.75. Difference = 23,704.86 − 23,211.75 = $493.12, so A costs $493.12 more in total even though its rate is lower and its monthly payment is $88.50 smaller. The longer term is what costs extra.

Try this example →

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the offer with the lower payment without looking at the total cost. In this example A has the lower rate and lower payment but costs more overall because it runs a year longer.
  • Reading the difference with the wrong sign. It is A minus B, so a positive number means A is the more expensive offer and a negative one means B is.
  • Entering the term in months. Both term fields are in years; 48 entered for a 4-year loan is read as a 48-year loan with a payment of only $128.55 and a total of $74,046.01 for offer B.
  • Typing a term that is not a whole number of months, such as 4.1 years. The tool shows no result; use 4.25 for 4 years 3 months, or whole years.
  • Comparing offers that carry different fees. Fees are not modelled, so an offer with a lower rate but a large origination fee can still be more expensive; check the APR as well.

About this calculator

Comparing two loan offers side by side means running the same loan amount through two different sets of terms — here a different interest rate and term length; fees are not modeled — to see which one actually costs less over the life of the loan, since the offer with the lower monthly payment isn't always the cheaper one overall. A longer term usually lowers the monthly payment but increases total interest paid, while a shorter term or lower rate does the opposite, so a side-by-side comparison of both the monthly payment and total cost is needed to make an informed choice.

Car buyers, mortgage shoppers, and personal-loan borrowers use this kind of comparison after collecting quotes from multiple lenders, banks, or credit unions, since lenders are required (in markets like the U.S. under TILA/Regulation Z) to disclose an APR (Annual Percentage Rate) that bundles interest and certain fees into one comparable figure — but buyers still benefit from seeing the raw monthly payment and total-cost breakdown side by side to understand exactly where the difference comes from.

Was this helpful?

You can pick up to 3 reactions.

Comments

  • Be the first to comment.

Popular calculators

All Calculators